menu-icon
cross

Higher CPA during Black Friday? Your campaign might still be performing well

Black Friday is approaching, and retailers are preparing to compete for consumer attention. But what happens to advertisers who aren't running holiday promotions?

A banking or investing app acquiring new users, for example, may find itself competing for advertising inventory during one of the busiest shopping periods of the year, even though its own acquisition goals haven't changed.

For mobile advertisers, this creates a challenge: acquisition costs can shift as competition increases, without an equivalent change in the value of the users being acquired.

So when cost per acquisition (CPA) rises during Black Fridayor Cyber Monday, how do you know whether the campaign needs adjusting?

Black Friday affects more than retail advertisers

During Black Friday and Cyber Monday (BFCM), retailers increase advertising activity to capture seasonal demand. In auction-based advertising environments, that increased competition can affect other advertisers targeting overlapping audiences and placements.

And there's evidence that businesses outside retail feel the impact too.

A 2026 analysis by Biddyco examined advertising costs across US Meta accounts during the 2025 holiday season. For apps and services, including software, finance, streaming and telecom, CPMs were 16% higher during BFCM week than their October baseline. On Black Friday itself, the increase reached 60%.

The study covers Meta advertising rather than the broader programmatic ecosystem, but it illustrates why businesses without a traditional holiday sales campaign still need to pay attention to seasonal advertising costs.

For mobile advertisers, though, the CPM increase matters less than what it does to the cost of a valuable user.

Your CPA increased. What changed?

An increase in CPA signals a change in the cost of acquiring users, but the metric alone doesn't explain the cause.

For an install-based mobile campaign, several factors contribute to acquisition efficiency:

  • CPM: How much the advertiser pays to reach users.
  • CTR: How often those impressions generate clicks.
  • Click-to-install rate: How effectively clicks turn into app installs.
  • Downstream conversion rate: How many acquired users complete a valuable action after installing.

Each metric can change independently, and their combined effect determines how much the advertiser ultimately pays for a valuable user.

Consider a simplified example:

Metric Before BFCM During BFCM
CPM $10 $13
CTR 1% 1%
Click-to-install rate 20% 20%
Cost per install $5.00 $6.50
Install-to-valuable-event rate 25% 25%
Cost per valuable event (CPA) $20.00 $26.00

In this scenario, CPM increases by 30%, while CTR and both conversion rates remain unchanged. The advertiser is paying more to acquire users, but there is no observed decline in their conversion quality.

That distinction changes the optimization decision.

Higher media costs and lower user quality require different responses

When acquisition performance changes during BFCM, advertisers need to identify where the difference is occurring.

Scenario 1: Media costs rise, but conversion quality holds

Imagine a banking app campaign where CPM increases during Black Friday, but click-to-install rates and downstream conversion rates remain consistent.

The campaign is still attracting users who behave similarly after acquisition. Reaching those users has simply become more expensive.

Pausing the campaign immediately could mean giving up valuable acquisition opportunities because of temporary auction conditions.

Instead, advertisers can compare performance across inventory sources, identify placements where costs have increased most sharply and consider reallocating budget toward sources that remain efficient.

But efficiency shouldn't be judged by media price alone.

The Association of National Advertisers' Q4 2025 Programmatic Transparency Benchmark found that advertisers with stronger media-quality controls directed a greater share of their programmatic spending toward impressions meeting defined quality criteria.

The report also described advertiser case studies where quality-focused optimization reduced cost per conversion despite higher nominal CPMs.

Although this research isn't specific to BFCM or mobile app acquisition, it highlights a risk when reallocating budgets: moving toward cheaper inventory may reduce media costs without improving acquisition performance.

Advertisers should therefore compare inventory sources using downstream outcomes and cost per valuable user, alongside CPM and CPI.

If those economics remain acceptable, maintaining the campaign while adjusting bids or inventory allocation may make sense. If acquisition costs exceed the value the campaign can support, reducing exposure may be necessary even when conversion quality remains stable.

Scenario 2: Acquisition costs rise and downstream performance declines

Now consider a campaign where CPI increases while the percentage of users completing a valuable in-app action appears to decrease.

Before treating this as a traffic-quality problem, advertisers should check whether the acquisition cohorts are comparable.

Are the users being compared at the same stage?

Many mobile campaigns optimize toward events that happen after the initial install.

A user may install a fintech app today but complete identity verification, activate an account or make their first transaction several days later.

Comparing users acquired during Black Friday with an earlier group that has had more time to convert can make the newer group appear less valuable simply because its conversion window is shorter.

A more meaningful comparison looks at acquisition cohorts at the same stage of their life cycle.

For example, advertisers could compare the percentage of users completing a valuable event within seven days of installation for a pre-BFCM cohort and a BFCM cohort, once both have had a full seven days to convert.

The appropriate window depends on the product and conversion event. Where valuable actions take longer, early indicators can help monitor performance, but incomplete cohorts shouldn't be treated as final evidence of declining user quality.

What if the decline is real?

If comparable cohorts show weaker downstream conversion, the next step is identifying where that decline originates.

Advertisers can examine performance by inventory source, placement or audience segment to see whether the change is concentrated in particular areas.

For a fintech app, a campaign may continue generating installs while fewer users complete verification or make their first transaction. In that situation, install volume alone can conceal a deterioration in acquisition quality.

If weaker performance is concentrated in specific sources, reducing bids, reallocating spend or tightening traffic selection may be appropriate. Sources that continue to deliver valuable users can be evaluated separately rather than applying the same adjustment across the entire campaign.

What should advertisers change during BFCM?

The analysis should lead to a few practical decisions:

Review inventory sources individually. Compare acquisition costs and downstream performance to identify where budget is delivering the strongest results.

Evaluate acquisition economics before adjusting spend. Use cost per valuable event and expected user value to determine whether higher media costs remain commercially acceptable.

Check conversion windows before judging recent traffic. Make sure apparent performance declines aren't being driven by incomplete cohort data.

Reassess after Cyber Monday. Revisit temporary bid adjustments and budget allocations as market conditions change.

These checks help advertisers make targeted adjustments while avoiding unnecessary disruption to campaigns that continue to acquire valuable users.

The value of a user doesn't change just because the auction does

Black Friday and Cyber Monday can create unusual conditions across the advertising ecosystem, including for businesses that have nothing to do with holiday shopping.

For mobile advertisers, rising acquisition costs deserve attention. But the response should depend on what's driving those costs and whether acquired users continue to deliver value.

At Creative Clicks, our focus is on acquiring users who deliver value after the install and making optimization decisions based on the performance that follows.

Looking to improve your mobile acquisition performance? Let's talk.

yellow graphic